|
Doing it Right: A Holistic Approach to Job Placement
Abstract
The two existing models of job placement, the selective and the
client-centered approaches, are riddled with inadequacies when dealing
with consumers of diverse culture. The problem is that many aspects
of human, organizational and environmental interactions are not
taken into account. Therefore, there exists a need to generate a
systems theory designed to holistically address the individualized
vocational rehabilitation needs of people with disabilities.
Systems theory became popular around 1935 toward the close of
the Hawthorne Studies. Simpson and Podsakoff (1975) state that "the
interdependence of the variables in a system is one of the widest
inductions from experience that we possess: for we may alternatively
regard it as the definition of a system." This concept describes
a social system in which the various aspects of the placement process
interact independently. In addition, other systems external to the
placement system also function interdependently with each other.
Therefore, each subsystem is dependent upon its basic characteristics
and variables as well as its interaction with other subsystems.
Viewing the placement process from an independent frame of reference
would be falling short of identifying all its components that interact
and lead to their functional or dysfunctional interactions.
In placement, it is necessary to identify the process as the “system.”
The placement process is comprised of two systems: 1) the internal
system which is comprised of the interactional patterns of the placement
process: client preparation for the world of work, counselors' qualifications
and competence, resources and reputation of the agency in placement
and 2) an external system, which contains in its environment the
labor market and geographical location of available jobs.
Currently, there is no objective and culturally appropriate model
of job placement that taps all of the resources/variables in the
task of facilitating community integration of consumers. There seems
to be no debate that the primary goal of vocational rehabilitation
is placing the consumer on a job that is meaningful. The question
of how to place the consumer is the debatable point.
A Systems Approach to Placement (SAP) affords placement professionals
in all settings a framework that incorporates the existing models
and offers a systematic and comprehensive approach to placement.
It suggests a "holistic" view of human, organizational
and environmental interaction from onset. SAP offers the professional
a new option that rejects neither the client-centered nor the selective
approach but adds an additional dimension to these existing models
by identifying multiple variables that account for the total functioning
of the process. In addition, the SAP reduces the chance of making
incorrect assumptions about the consumer’s assets and limitations
when evaluating him/her for a job or for entry into the vocational
rehabilitation process. It offers a diagnostic approach for the
practitioner to better identify the placement subsystems that need
to be considered for each individual consumer.
The main ingredient of a system is an organism, organization, or
individual. A system is an identifiable organization or a whole
that is made up of parts that react and/or interact with each other
to maintain a sense of balance. The SAP is built to view the placement
process as a system with the identification of eight subsystems
that play an important part in the placement process.
1. The Client "Subsystem"—The client as a whole
and how he/she relates to the external and internal environment.
2. The Health "Subsystem"—The consumer’s
general health as well as an assessment of his/her disabling conditions.
3. The Education "Subsystem"—All training both
formal and informal.
4. The Family "Subsystem"—The interaction of the
consumer with his/her family.
5. The Society "Subsystem"—the impact of culture
and society external to the family.
6. The Employer "Subsystem"—Consists of —human,
organizational, and physical—that relate to the workplace.
7. The Placement Counselor-Placement Personnel "Subsystem"—Variables
related to the professionals who do job placement.
8. The Funding "Subsystem"—Federal financial aid
that assists the placement system, specifically from the Department
of Education. Complex reaction and interaction of the above factors
determine the long-term placement outcome.
|